Rules in flux Several rules that affect new grads are proposed or in court. Policy Tracker

Moving & Money

Leaving Canada, and your RRSP, TFSA and FHSA

When CRA treats you as a non-resident, departure tax, what to do with registered accounts, and US reporting of your Canadian accounts.

Last checked Re-check: each tax season

General information, not legal or tax advice. Border decisions are up to the officer, and rules here change often. For your own situation, talk to a licensed immigration lawyer or a cross-border tax professional.

Get a cross-border tax preparer for your departure year. The departure-year Canadian return, TFSA and FHSA treatment after you move, and a dual-status US return are all areas where the research behind this page recommends professional help.

When you become a non-resident#

  • The rule. You become a non-resident when you sever your residential ties to Canada. The date is usually the latest of three: when you leave, when your spouse or dependants leave, or when you become a US resident (CRA: Leaving Canada) Official.
  • Form NR73 asks CRA for an opinion on your residency status, and is optional (CRA NR73) Official.
  • If both countries treat you as resident, the Canada–US tax treaty settles it with a tie-breaker. It looks at these in order: permanent home, centre of vital interests, habitual abode, citizenship, then mutual agreement between the two tax agencies (Tohme Accounting) Secondary.

Departure tax#

  • What it is. When you leave, CRA treats you as having sold most of your property at fair market value (a "deemed disposition"), and taxes any gain (CRA: Dispositions) Official.
  • What's excluded. RRSPs, TFSAs, RRIFs, pensions and Canadian real estate.
  • The forms:
  • T1243 calculates the tax.
  • T1244 defers it. Elect by April 30; you have to give CRA security if the deferred tax is over $16,500.
  • T1161 lists your property, and is required if it was worth over $25,000 in total. The late penalty is $25 a day, from $100 up to $2,500.
  • Which assets count toward that $25,000 hasn't been verified here Unverified.

The departure-year return#

When you file your Canadian return for the year you leave (CRA: Leaving Canada) Official:

  • Enter your departure date.
  • Report your world income up to that date, and only Canadian-source income after it.
  • Don't count on deducting moving costs. Costs to leave Canada are generally not deductible.
  • Tell your Canadian banks and other payers that you're now a non-resident.
  • Time-sensitive Benefits may stop. Non-residents generally can't get the Canada Groceries and Essentials Benefit, and benefit names change from year to year.

TFSA#

  • Stop contributing once you're a non-resident. After that, contributions are taxed 1% a month until you withdraw them, plus a separate tax on any over-contribution (CRA: TFSA and non-residents; Income Tax Act s. 207.03) Official.
  • The US doesn't recognize the TFSA. Income earned inside it is taxable in the US (Taxes for Expats) Secondary.
  • US reporting is disputed. Disputed Practitioners disagree on whether you need US Form 3520 for a TFSA. Canadian funds held inside are likely PFICs, a US category with heavy reporting rules (Greenback; Advisor.ca) Secondary.
  • Max it out before you leave. Contributing what room you have before your departure date, then stopping, is this site's suggestion Site analysis. Whether to close a TFSA after moving is a call to make with an advisor.

RRSP#

  • US tax deferral is automatic under Rev. Proc. 2014-55, and the old Form 8891 is no longer used (Rev. Proc. 2014-55) Official.
  • Unused contribution room carries forward (Sun Life) Secondary.
  • Withdrawals as a non-resident have 25% tax withheld by default.
  • US states may not follow the treaty for RRSPs. Not yet researched Unverified.

FHSA#

  • You can keep it, but you can't make a qualifying home-purchase withdrawal while you're a non-resident. Taxable withdrawals have 25% withheld (CRA: Non-residents and FHSAs) Official.
  • Contributing after you leave is disputed. Disputed Sources conflict on whether non-residents can keep contributing (TaxTips vs. Mondaq) Secondary.

Reporting Canadian accounts to the US#

Both rules below are from the IRS comparison of Form 8938 and FBAR Official.

  • FBAR (FinCEN 114). Required if your foreign accounts add up to more than $10,000 at any point in the year. It's due April 15, with an automatic extension to October 15.
  • Form 8938. Required for a single filer living in the US with over $50,000 at year end, or over $75,000 at any point in the year.